The Dance of Black Holes

8. 5. 2014 | A pair of supermassive black holes orbiting one another have been discovered by an international research team, including Stefanie Komossa from the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn, Germany. This pair was found because they were ripping apart a star when ESA's space observatory XMM-Newton happened to be looking in their direction.
Purely coincidentally, the XMM-Newton X-ray observatory glanced in the direction of these two black holes that were "devouring" a star at that very moment. This is the first time a pair of black holes was found in an ordinary galaxy. Most massive galaxies in the Universe are thought to have at least one supermassive black hole in their centre. Two supermassive black holes are a smoking gun that the galaxy has merged with another galaxy. Thus finding binary supermassive black holes can tell astronomers about how galaxies evolved into their present shapes and sizes.
Two black holes
Bild vergrößern
(© ESA / C. Carreau)

Two black holes | in close proximity: one of them is accreting the 'debris' of a disrupted star, while the second is temporarily interrupting the stream of gas towards the other black hole (artist's impression).

To date, only few candidates for close binary supermassive black holes have been found. But all of these are in "active galaxies" where they are constantly ripping gas clouds apart. In this process, the gas is heated considerably until it shines at many wavelengths, including X-rays. This gives these galaxies an unusually bright centre - that's why they're called "active". The new discovery is important because it is the first black hole pair to be found in a galaxy that is not active in this sense.

Dr. Stefanie Komossa
Bild vergrößern
Dr. Stefanie Komossa
"There might be a whole population of quiescent galaxies that host binary black holes in their centres," says co-author Stefanie Komossa from the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn, Germany. But finding them is difficult because in quiescent galaxies, there are no gas clouds feeding the black holes, and so the cores of these galaxies are truly dark. The only hope that astronomers have is that they happen to look in the right direction at the right time: when one of the black holes is ripping a star to pieces. Such an event is called "tidal disruption event": as the star is pulled apart by the gravity of the black hole, it shows an X-ray flare. In order to increase the chances of catching an event like this, researchers employed ESA's X-ray observatory XMM-Newton in a novel way.

Normally, the observatory collects data from designated targets, one at a time. Once it completes an observation, it slews to the next. But during this movement, XMM-Newton keeps the instruments turned on and keeps recording. The result is a random sky survey, producing data that can be analysed for unknown or unexpected X-ray sources. On 10 June 2010, an event was spotted by XMM-Newton in the galaxy "SDSS J120136.02+300305.5", approximately 2 billion light years away. Komossa and her colleagues had been scanning the data for events like this and were thus able to schedule follow-up observations just days later with XMM-Newton, and with NASA's Swift satellite. The galaxy was still radiating X-rays into space, and they looked exactly like a tidal disruption event.

But as the researchers tracked the slowly fading emission day after day something strange happened: The X-rays fell below detectable levels between days 27 and 48 after the discovery. Then they re-appeared and continued to follow the expected fading rate again, as if nothing had happened. Thanks to Fukun Liu, astronomer from Peking University in China and lead author of the study, this odd behaviour could be explained: "This is exactly what you would expect from a pair of supermassive black holes orbiting one another," Liu explains. He had been working on models of black hole binary systems and had predicted a sudden plunge to darkness with a subsequent recovery, because the gravity of one of the black holes could disrupt the flow of gas onto the other, temporarily depriving it of fuel to fire the X-ray flare.

Now that astronomers have found this first candidate for a binary black hole in a quiescent galaxy, the search is on for more. XMM-Newton will continue its slew survey. "Once we have detected thousands of tidal disruption events, we can begin to extract reliable statistics about the rate at which galaxies merge," Stefanie Komossa predicts.   (© Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy, AcademiaNet)
Norbert Junkes

More information


  1. Read what our members say about AcademiaNet.

No more excuses!

  1. Please download the brochure "No more excuses" and read more about female experts in Europe, and about AcademiaNet.


  1. Spinning like a spider

    AcademiaNet welcomes its 2500 member this week – Dr Anna Rising from Karolinska Institutet and Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. To celebrate, we called Dr Rising and chatted about her research on spider silk, her start-up company Spiber Technologies and life as a woman in science.

  2. Professor Dame Anne Glover is Elected as the New RSE President

    AcademiaNet member Dame Anne Glover will start her appointment as president of the Royal Society of Edinburgh in April 2018. She will supersede another AcademiaNet scientist, current president Dame Jocelyn Bell Burnell.

  3. Into oppression, for God and false promises

    Of late, an increased number of young women is joining radical Islam and departing for Syria to support the so-called Islamic State (IS). Leaving an, in our eyes, liberal world, they voluntarily enter a system of total surveillance and oppression. Professor Susanne Schröter addresses the motives of these young women and investigates what will await them there.

  4. ERC Starting Grant for Caroline Gutjahr

    The AcademiaNet scientist secures a 1.5 Mio. € grant to support her research on mycorrhiza.

  5. The first black holes keep revealing secrets about our universe

    Ancient black holes hidden away in deep space have left behind nuclear clues about the first-ever stars, according to Professor Raffaella Schneider from the Department of Physics of Sapienza University of Rome, Italy, who leads a team of stellar archaeologists.